Reading 4

 1. Summary

The article argues that understanding Wikipedia requires appreciating its community and collaborative culture, but also recognizing the challenges it faces from personal differences and external threats. Despite its collaborative nature, Wikipedia has been shaped by authorial leadership, with an informal benevolent dictator guiding the community and mediating disputes. However, this leadership role can be challenging to balance, as new responsibilities and authority may arise. The article uses examples, such as Sanger's reflections on his departure from the community and discussions about Wales's role, to illustrate the delicate balance of leadership in the Wikipedia community.

2. Interesting

As an AI language model, I do not have personal opinions, but I can identify some points that may be interesting to readers. One interesting point is how the author describes the culture and community of Wikipedia and how it has been shaped by authorial leadership. The idea of an informal benevolent dictator guiding the community and how this can lead to a significant amount of symbolic status within and outside the community is also interesting. The discussion about the delicate balance of leadership responsibilities and authority is another point of interest, as well as the reflections of one of Wikipedia's co-founders, Larry Sanger, on his exit from the community and the role of Wikipedia's other co-founder, Jimmy Wales.

3. Discussion

There are several ways to discuss this article. Here are a few potential discussion topics:

  1. The role of community in Wikipedia: The article highlights the importance of the collaborative culture and community in shaping Wikipedia. Do you agree with this assessment? Why or why not? How does the community-based model of Wikipedia compare to other online communities?

  2. Authorial leadership and community governance: The article notes that while Wikipedia is guided by an informal benevolent dictator, it is ultimately shaped by the community. How does this balance between leadership and community governance work in practice? Can you think of other examples of online communities that balance these two forces?

  3. Challenges facing Wikipedia: The article also discusses some of the challenges facing Wikipedia, including philosophical differences and external threats. What are some of the key challenges that Wikipedia faces today? How can these challenges be addressed while maintaining Wikipedia's commitment to openness and collaboration?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reading2：LI XINWEI

  1)  Summary    Wikipedia has a long history of development and it didn't happen overnight. Wikipedia couldn't have developed without all the people who had ideas to benefit the world. Wikipedia is free and does not exist for profit. As the internet grew and became more widely used, people began to plan and build interpedia. The "sum of all human knowledge" is the ultimate goal of Wikipedia, and the World Encyclopedia is the repository of knowledge to which all humanity aspires. The "necessary conditions" for the emergence of Wikipedia 2) Interesting point   “To collect all the knowledge now scattered over the surface of the earth, to make its general structure known to those around us, and to spread it to those who come after us.”   Regardless of their wealth, social status or academic background, people have the opportunity to participate in the editing of Wikipedia, sharing their experiences or knowledge to all people through this Wikipedia that covers t
Read more

Summary of reading material 1----HE YUNONG (3.10)

  Summary of reading material 1 --HE YUNONG (하우농) 1. Summary After reading these articles, I learned more about Wikipedia. As mentioned in the article, no one would have imagined that Wikipedia could become the top website today. Before I took the course taught, I was also a person who had only heard of wiki but could not use or understand what Wikipedia was, including wiki voyage, wiki data, etc. Because I have never been taught, I am very grateful to the professor for letting me know about wiki and joining wiki. I understand that the core of wiki is a collaborative community, where many volunteers freely and voluntarily share their knowledge; Children as young as seven or eight years old and elderly people can become volunteers in wiki. One of the characteristics of wiki is that it is free and unpaid, so all wiki people don't work on wiki for money, but to love and help others. Wiki can develop into such a top-level website today without the efforts of these volunteers, and I thi
Read more

Reading 14: ZENG WANTING

  1） Summarize of metirals Wikipedia has millions of editors, the population is larger than many counties. If we know about wikipedia cultures, we can know a new, complex, virtual culture can arise within barely a decade and it will improve our skills at editng wikipedia, reducing tensions and imrovinh ours familiarity with the project. When we editing the article of the wikipedia, we are contacting with other people we are not working alone. Wikipedia is a community, people work together and have communications with others. Wikipedia culture is significant enough th have impact on th real world. Wikipedia values related to th efree culture movement have influrenced legislation in the USA and elsewhere. Overall, Wikipedia's vibrant culture and the dedication of its community have played a significant role in creating a vast and reliable knowledge resource available to people worldwide. 2） Something interseting I learned The wikipeidia uesrs are called as wikipedian by their languag
Read more